Just above passing.....
I understand you said you put no sound in it... but it still needed it. Even if it was just a little song/loop from the audio portal.
Also I found the animation to be a little choppy.
Plus the graphics weren't much, but I'm not docking you too much on that because, let's face it, frame by frames are hard.
As I said in the summary, all together it's a barely acceptable film. I'm sure if you try harder, you can do better.